Everton 3 : 1 United

There are somethings about home-advantage in football I find difficult to comprehend. It's the same pitch and ball you play with and yet some teams seem to totally get into a new Avataar when playing at home and dangerously so. Burnley have been a classic example this season (just one point away against 22 at home!). Teams like Fulham, West Ham, Aston Villa are sometimes more difficult to play away than some of the top 4. I'm sure people will readily point out it's the crowd support that makes the difference. But is it that difficult for modern-day professional footballers (who I am sure get enough training on staying mentally tough) to negate the influence of opposite teams' crowd support on their games? Or am I undermining the strength of the proverbial twelfth man in football?

Everton are not a team to be left behind in this debate because they are always a tough team to play in their backyard. And how well they vindicated that fact yesterday!

Fresh from defeating Chelsea less than 2 weeks ago and smarting from a narrow derby loss, Everton was not the best place to visit around this time. Specially for United who were coming off a hard earned victory at Milan. It was a little surprising Sir Alex went into this one with a 4-4-2 and not the time tested 4-5-1 that has been so productive this season in terms of results. You could see the effects straight-away - Everton seemed to enjoy bullying United midfield as the game got into its stride. The flip side though was that United went ahead through a nicely taken goal by Berbatov, a player who wouldn't have featured if United had gone with a lone striker! Everton shot right back through Bilyaletdinov's stunning goal, a thunder-bolt really! All this within the first 20 minutes and it seemed that we could be up for a goal fest! Rooney could easily have scored United's second had it not been for that one touch he took after rounding off Tim Howard that was wee bit heavy. Overall, first half was mostly an end-to-end affair with some really exciting football to watch.

Second half looked a bit cagey unlike the first for a good 15 minutes. But after that it was all Everton. The second string United defense of Browne and Evans looked more and more shaky.

Everton began to boss the proceedings and eventually resulted in their second goal. United pushed hard for the equalizer but seemed to lack the sting, specially with Rooney having an off day at his old club. Everton finally finished off United in the 90th minute through a brilliant solo effort from teenager Jack Rodwell.

The game was mainly lost in the midfield, I would say. I am quite sure a 5 man United mid-field would have definitely dented Everton's game. But then, United also looked tired as a unit and you can't play the aging Scholes week-in week-out! Browne and Evans struggled to say the least and I feel that was the clinching factor as far as this game was concerned.

So, it's 6 losses so far this season and we still have about 11 games to go! My initial assessment at the start of the season was that United would struggle due to the lack of goals after Ronaldo's departure. But I now realize that United's defense is more crucial to their prospects than their frontline. Last season, United came up with one of the least goal tallies to win the title (oh yeah, Ronaldo was still with us!) and that was largely due to the exploits of the Vidic and Ferdinand's partnership along with that of Van der Saar. United always score goals because of the way they play their game (and we must be so thankful for that!) But this season has been an absolute testament to the fact that United's defense is perhaps more vital to their title aspirations than their frontline.

Obviously, the season is not over yet and how we should be happy about that. Any other season and 6 defeats would have meant good-bye to the title! Yet this season, freak as it is, a couple of slip-ups by Chelsea and United could still sneak away with the title. Can't wait for Chelsea to come to Old Trafford!